Almost all term sheets provide that they are not binding, except for certain provisions regarding exclusivity, confidentiality and/or expenses (all of which I will cover in a later post) depending on the term sheet. An investor can refuse to complete the financing at any time if the term sheet isn’t binding. I’ve heard of many situations where a company had a signed term sheet and the financing never occurred. A company has very little practical recourse if a venture fund fails to complete a financing after signing a non-binding term sheet. However, there is a California case that held that a document intended to outline the terms of a proposed transaction may impose a duty to negotiate in good faith on the parties.
What do definitive documents for a Series A financing look like?
The National Venture Capital Association has posted model venture capital financing documents on its web site.
The principal documents in a Series A financing include:
- Stock Purchase Agreement
- Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation
- Investor Rights Agreement
- Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale Agreement
- Voting Agreement
In addition, there is a schedule of exceptions, legal opinion, officer’s certificate, secretary’s certificate, management rights letters, indemnification agreements, form of confidential information and invention assignment agreement, board consent, stockholder consent, good standing certificates, stock certificates, along with any documents to deal with deferred corporate housekeeping.
Most law firms actively involved in representing companies or investors in venture capital financings have their own forms, including WSGR. In fact, WSGR has invested time and resources in developing a Series A document automation system that produces an initial draft of financing documents after completing a TurboTax-style online questionnaire. Attorneys still need to review and further customize the drafts, but this document automation system allows attorneys to circulate initial drafts of documents quickly and reduce time in marking up form documents. WSGR also has an automated system to create the various documents involved in an incorporation of a typical Delaware company.
Entrepreneurs should not read the NVCA documents and conclude that the default provisions represent a “middle of the road” outcome between the company and investors. There is an “East Coast” bias in the documents, which means the documents are more investor favorable than “West Coast” market practice. Given that California alone represents over 40% of venture capital financing transactions in the United States, I don’t think that these documents accurately reflect what is customary in financings. In addition, there are some technical issues with the documents that need to be addressed.
What does a Series A term sheet look like?
CONFIDENTIAL
[NAME OF ISSUER]
MEMORANDUM OF TERMS
[Except with respect to the provisions entitled [“Exclusive negotiations“] [and] [“Confidentiality“], which are intended to be, and are, legally binding agreements among the parties hereto, this] [This] Memorandum of Terms represents only the current thinking of the parties with respect to certain of the major issues relating to the proposed private offering and does not constitute a legally binding agreement. This Memorandum of Terms does not constitute an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy securities in any state where the offer or sale is not permitted.
THE OFFERING
Issuer: [__________], a [Delaware] corporation (the “Company“)
Securities: Series [A] Preferred Stock (the “Preferred”)
Valuation of the Company: $[__________] pre-money
Amount of the offering: $[__________]
Number of shares: [__________] shares
Price per share: $[__________]
Investor(s): [__________] or its affiliated entities (the lead investor(s)), [__________] and other investors acceptable to the Company.
Capitalization: See Exhibit A for the pre-financing capitalization of the Company [and the pro forma capitalization following the proposed offering].
Anticipated closing date: Initial closing on or before [__________], with one or more additional closings within [60] days thereafter.
TERMS OF THE PREFERRED
Dividends: Non-cumulative dividends at an annual rate of 8% of the purchase price per share in preference to the common stock, when and if declared by the board. Any dividends in excess of the preference will be paid to the common stock.
Liquidation preference: In the event of a liquidation, dissolution or winding up of the Company, the Preferred will have the right to receive the original purchase price plus any declared but unpaid dividends prior to any distribution to the common stock. The remaining assets will be distributed pro rata to the holders of Preferred and the holders of common stock on an as-converted basis[, provided that the total amount distributed to the Preferred (including the initial liquidation preference) will be limited to [__________] times the initial liquidation preference]. A sale of all or substantially all of the Company’s assets or a merger or consolidation of the Company with any other company will be treated as a liquidation of the Company.
Redemption: The Preferred will not have redemption rights.
Conversion: The Preferred may be converted at any time, at the option of the holder, into shares of common stock. The conversion rate will initially be 1:1, subject to anti-dilution and other customary adjustments.
Automatic conversion: Each share of Preferred will automatically convert into common stock, at the then applicable conversion rate, upon (i) the closing of a firmly underwritten public offering of common stock at a price per share that is at least [three] times the purchase price of the Preferred with gross offering proceeds in excess of $[__________] million (a “Qualified Public Offering“), or (ii) the consent of the holders of at least [50]% of the then outstanding shares of Preferred.
Anti-dilution: The conversion price of the Preferred (which will initially equal the purchase price of the Preferred) will be subject to adjustment, on a broad-based weighted average basis, if the Company issues additional securities at a price per share less than the then applicable conversion price.
There will be no adjustment to the conversion price for issuances of (i) shares issued upon conversion of the Preferred; (ii) shares or options, warrants or other rights issued to employees, consultants or directors in accordance with plans, agreements or similar arrangements, but not to exceed a total of [__________] shares issued after the closing date [or such greater number as unanimously approved by the board]; (iii) shares issued upon exercise of options, warrants or convertible securities existing on the closing date; (iv) shares issued as a dividend or distribution on Preferred or for which adjustment is otherwise made pursuant to the certificate of incorporation (e.g., stock splits); (v) shares issued in connection with a registered public offering; (vi) shares issued or issuable pursuant to an acquisition of another corporation or a joint venture agreement approved by the board; (vii) shares issued or issuable to banks, equipment lessors or other financial institutions pursuant to debt financing or commercial transactions approved by the board; (viii) shares issued or issuable in connection with any settlement approved by the board; (ix) shares issued or issuable in connection with sponsored research, collaboration, technology license, development, OEM, marketing or other similar arrangements or strategic partnerships approved by the board; (x) shares issued to suppliers of goods or services in connection with the provision of goods or services pursuant to transactions approved by the board; or (xi) shares that are otherwise excluded by consent of holders of a majority of the Preferred.
General voting rights: Each share of Preferred will have the right to a number of votes equal to the number of shares of common stock issuable upon conversion of each such share of Preferred. The Preferred will vote with the common stock on all matters except as specifically provided herein or as otherwise required by law.
Voting for directors: [So long as [__________]% of the Preferred is outstanding, the] [The] holders of Preferred will be entitled to elect [two] director[s]. The holders of common stock will be entitled to elect [two] director[s]. The remaining director(s) will be elected by the holders of Preferred and common stock voting together.
Protective provisions: So long as [any] of the Preferred is outstanding, consent of the holders of at least [50]% of the Preferred will be required for any action that (i) alters any provision of the certificate of incorporation [or the bylaws] if it would [adversely] alter the rights, preferences, privileges or powers of or restrictions on the preferred stock or any series of preferred; (ii) changes the authorized number of shares of preferred stock or any series of preferred; (iii) authorizes or creates any new class or series of shares having rights, preferences or privileges with respect to dividends or liquidation senior to or on a parity with the Preferred or having voting rights other than those granted to the preferred stock generally; (iv) approves any merger, sale of assets or other corporate reorganization or acquisition; (v) approves the purchase, redemption or other acquisition of any common stock of the Company, other than repurchases pursuant to stock restriction agreements approved by the board upon termination of a consultant, director or employee; (vi) declares or pays any dividend or distribution with respect to the [preferred stock (except as otherwise provided in the certificate of incorporation) or] common stock; [or] (vii) approves the liquidation or dissolution of the Company[; (viii)Â increases the size of the board;] [(ix) encumbers or grants a security interest in all or substantially all of the assets of the Company in connection with an indebtedness of the Company;] [(x) acquires a material amount of assets through a merger or purchase of all or substantially all of the assets or capital stock of another entity;] [or (xi) increases the number of shares authorized for issuance under any existing stock or option plan or creates any new stock or option plan].
INVESTOR RIGHTS
Information rights: The Company will deliver to each holder of at least [500,000] shares of Preferred, (i) [un]audited annual financial statements within [90] days following year-end, (ii) unaudited quarterly financial statements within [45] days following quarter-end, (iii) unaudited monthly financial statements within [30] days of month-end, and (iv) annual business plans. The information rights will terminate upon an initial public offering.
Registration rights:
Registrable securities. The common stock issued or issuable upon conversion of the Preferred will be “Registrable Securities.”
Demand registration. Subject to customary exceptions, holders of at least [50]% of the Registrable Securities will be entitled to demand that the Company effect up to [two] registrations (provided that each such registration has an offering price of at least $[10.00] per share with aggregate proceeds of at least $[20] million) at any time following the earlier of (i) [five] years following the closing of the financing and (ii) 180 days following the Company’s initial public offering. The Company will have the right to delay such registration under certain circumstances for [up to] [two] period[s] of up to [90] days [each] in any twelve month period.
“Piggyback” registration. The holders of Registrable Securities will be entitled to “piggyback” registration rights on any registered offering by the Company on its own behalf or on behalf of selling stockholders, subject to customary exceptions. In an underwritten offering, the managing underwriters will have the right, in the event of marketing limitations, to limit the number of Registrable Securities included in the offering, provided that, in an offering other than the initial public offering, the Registrable Securities may not be limited to less than [25]% of the total offering. In the event of such marketing limitations, each holder of Registrable Securities will have the right to include shares on a pro rata basis as among all such holders and to include shares in preference to any other holders of common stock.
S-3 rights. Subject to customary exceptions, holders of Registrable Securities will be entitled to an unlimited number of demand registrations on Form S-3 (if available to the Company) so long as those registered offerings are each for common stock having an aggregate offering price of not less than [$1,000,000]. The Company will not be required to file more than [two] such Form S-3 registration statements in any twelve month period.
Expenses. Subject to customary exceptions, the Company will bear the registration expenses (exclusive of underwriting discounts and commissions) of all demand, piggyback and S-3 registrations, provided that the Company will not be required to pay the fees of more than one counsel to all holders of Registrable Securities.
Termination. The registration rights of a holder of Registrable Securities will terminate on the earlier of (i) such date, on or after the Company’s initial public offering, on which such holder may immediately sell all shares of its Registrable Securities under Rule 144 during any 90-day period and (ii) [three] years after the initial public offering.
Market stand-off. Holders of Registrable Securities will agree not to effect any transactions with respect to any of the Company’s securities within 180 days following the Company’s initial public offering[, provided that all officers, directors and 1% stockholders of the Company are similarly bound].
Other provisions. The Investor Rights Agreement will contain such other provisions with respect to registration rights as are customary, including with respect to indemnification, underwriting arrangements and restrictions on the grant of future registration rights.
Right to maintain proportionate ownership: Each holder of at least [500,000] shares of Preferred will have a right to purchase its pro rata share of any offering of new securities by the Company, subject to customary exceptions. The pro rata share will be based on the ratio of (x) the number of shares of Preferred held by such holder (on an as-converted basis) to (y) [the Company’s fully-diluted capitalization (on an as-converted and as-exercised basis)]. [Participating holders will have the right to purchase, on a pro rata basis, any shares as to which eligible holders do not exercise their rights.] This right will terminate immediately prior to the Company’s initial public offering [or five years after the financing].
Right of first refusal and co-sale agreement: In the event [__________] proposes to transfer any Company shares, the Company will have a right of first refusal to purchase the shares on the same terms as the proposed transfer.
If the Company does not exercise its right of first refusal, holders of Preferred will have a right of first refusal (on a pro rata basis among holders of Preferred) with respect to the proposed transfer. [Rights to purchase any unsubscribed shares will be reallocated pro rata among the other eligible holders of Preferred.]
To the extent the rights of first refusal are not exercised, the holders of Preferred will have the right to participate in the proposed transfer on a pro rata basis (as among the transferee and the holders of Preferred).
The rights of first refusal and co-sale rights will be subject to customary exceptions and will terminate on an initial public offering.
[“Drag–along” right: Subject to customary exceptions, if holders of [50]% of the Preferred approve a proposed sale of the Company to a third party (whether structured as a merger, reorganization, asset sale or otherwise), [__________] will agree to approve the proposed sale. This right will terminate upon a Qualified Public Offering.]
Board representation: [The principal stockholders of the Company will agree to elect to the board [__________] representative[s] of [__________], [__________] representative[s] of [__________] and [__________] mutually agreeable person[s].] The directors will be entitled to customary indemnification from the Company and reimbursement of reasonable costs of attendance at board meetings.
EMPLOYEE MATTERS
Vesting of founder shares: Shares and options held by [__________] will be subject to [four-year vesting], with [25]% vesting on the first anniversary of [the commencement of services] and the remainder vesting [monthly] thereafter. The Company will have the right, upon termination of services, to repurchase any unvested shares.
Vesting of employee shares: Subject to the discretion of the board, shares and options issued to employees, directors and consultants will be subject to [four-year vesting], with [25]% vesting on the first anniversary of the commencement of services and the remainder vesting [monthly] thereafter. The Company will have the right, upon termination of services, to repurchase any unvested shares.
Proprietary information agreements: The Company will have all employees and consultants enter into proprietary information and inventions agreements in a form reasonably satisfactory to the investors.
[“Key person” life insurance: The Company will obtain a “key person” life insurance policy on [__________] in the amount of $[__________], with proceeds payable to the Company.]
OTHER MATTERS
Legal fees and expenses: The Company will pay the reasonable fees and expenses of a single counsel to the investors [up to a maximum of $[__________]].
[Exclusive negotiations: From the date of the execution of this Memorandum of Terms until the earlier of (i) [__________], (ii) notice of termination of negotiations by the lead investor(s) and (iii) the initial closing of the financing contemplated by this Memorandum of Terms, neither the Company nor any of its directors, officers, employees or agents will solicit, or participate in negotiations or discussions with respect to, any other investment in, or acquisition of, the Company without the prior consent of the lead investor(s). [The lead investor(s) consent to the Company soliciting, and participating in negotiations and discussions with, [__________].]
[Confidentiality: Until the initial closing of the financing contemplated by this Memorandum of Terms, the existence and terms of this Memorandum of Terms shall not be disclosed to any third party without the consent of the Company and the lead investor(s), except as may be (i) reasonably required to consummate the transactions contemplated hereby or (ii) required by law.]
Conditions precedent: The investment will be subject to customary conditions, including but not limited to:
Completion of due diligence to the satisfaction of the investors;
Negotiation and execution of definitive agreements customary in transactions of this nature;
Receipt of all required authorizations, approvals and consents;
Delivery of customary closing certificates [and an opinion of counsel for the Company]; and
The absence of material adverse changes with respect to the Company.
(Signature page follows)
This Memorandum of Terms may be executed in counterparts, which together will constitute one document. Facsimile signatures shall have the same legal effect as original signatures.
Who pays legal fees in a convertible note bridge financing and how much does it cost?
In deals where investors don’t have counsel, the term sheet usually says that each party will bear its own legal fees and expenses. It wouldn’t be unusual for investors to not engage counsel in an early stage convertible note financing with friends and family. If one of the investors wants to have the documents reviewed by counsel, those fees typically are paid by the company, which is customary in any VC financing. The amount of fees to investor counsel can be as low as $2500 for a quick look at documents and no due diligence in a seed stage deal, to over $15K, depending on the amount of diligence and the complexity of the documents. Investor’s counsel may conduct UCC searches and extensive due diligence, especially if the note is secured. In complex deals, investor’s counsel fees may exceed $50K to $100K. Investor counsel fees payable by the company are typically capped, with the investors responsible for any excess over the cap.
Company counsel fees could be under $10K if there is no negotiation on terms and a single investor to over $30K if there is extensive due diligence and complexity. Company counsel fees on convertible loans may exceed $100K for later stage companies or extremely complicated deals. Company counsel fees are higher than investor’s counsel fees because company counsel drafts documents (on the West Coast) and needs to solve diligence issues. In addition, there is typically some deferred corporate housekeeping that needs to be done by company counsel before the financing.
Why should a majority of investors be able to amend the convertible notes?
In the event a company needs to amend or waive a provision in the notes, absent a provision that says that the note can be amended or waived with the consent of holders of a majority in interest of the notes, the company has to get every single investor to agree to the amendment or waiver. This ends up being difficult as a practical matter if certain investors are unavailable or refuse to sign an amendment or waiver. Typical situations where a company may want to amend or waive a provision of the note might include extension of the maturity date, changing the terms of the automatic conversion on a qualified equity financing, etc. Majority is measured by the principal amount of the notes. The majority trigger may be set higher to two-thirds or seventy-five percent depending on the situation.
What should the representation and warranties in the note purchase agreement be?
Some investors are perfectly willing to purchase notes without receiving particularly extensive representations and warranties from the company. Other investors want the same level of detailed representations and warranties as a typical VC Series A financing. Generally, I think that if there is a bridge loan after a Series A financing, the investors should receive the same level of representations and warranties that the previous Series A investors received. This means that the company probably needs to prepare a detailed schedule of exceptions or disclosure schedule to disclose things required by the representations and warranties. Representations and warranties in seed stage bridge financings generally will be less extensive than in VC Series A financings, which probably reflects the fact that representations and warranties for an early stage company are not necessarily meaningful because there is very little to disclose. In addition, as a practical matter, the recourse for a breach of representations and warranties generally is a claim against the company for damages. Making a claim for damages against an early stage company without any money may be futile.
What is a security interest in connection with a convertible note?
A security agreement creates a security interest in certain company assets. This allows the investor to take certain actions upon non-payment of the loan. The investor (or a collateral agent acting for the investors) may take possession of and sell the collateral and apply the proceeds to the repay the debt. If the proceeds of the sale exceed the amount of the debt, the company is entitled to the excess.
In order for the rights of the investor to become enforceable against third parties with respect to the collateral, the holder must “perfect” the security interest. Perfection is typically achieved by filing a document called a UCC financing statement with the secretary of state where the corporation is located. The investor will not be able to enforce its rights in the collateral against third parties, such as other creditors who claim a security interest in the same collateral or a trustee in bankruptcy, without “perfecting” the security interest.
Security interests are rare in seed stage convertible note bridge financings and not particularly common in bridge loans for venture backed companies, unless the loan is particularly risky, such as in connection with a bridge to a sale of company when the company is running out of money.
What does subordination mean in a convertible bridge note?
In the event of default, creditors with subordinated debt don’t get paid until after holders of senior debt are paid in full. Startup companies may ask holders of convertible bridge notes to subordinate their debt to existing and future senior debt from banks and other lenders. (Of course, most seed stage startup companies are unlikely to be credit worthy enough for this type of debt, so subordination provisions may be irrelevant for many startups.) Subordination provisions provide the company with the flexibility to incur senior debt without going back to the holders of notes for consent. However, many banks will request that their own form of subordination agreement be signed by holders of notes instead of relying upon the subordination provisions contained in a typical convertible note. A subordinated convertible note will define types of senior indebtedness and sometimes will place a cap on the maximum amount of senior indebtedness that may be incurred by a company.
Traditionally, equipment leasing facilities and equipment loan facilities, which are secured solely by the equipment financed, are not treated as senior indebtedness (nor are they typically subordinated to other forms of a company’s indebtedness). However in certain circumstances, this type of financing may be deemed to be senior indebtedness (i.e., if secured by a blanket lien).
Can you have multiple closings in a convertible note bridge financing?
Of course. Depending on the situation, additional closings can continue to be held for up to a fixed period of time (such as 30, 60, 90, 120, 180 days or even one year) after the first closing or anytime at the discretion of the board of directors. If there are additional closings, please keep in mind that (1) interest calculations on each note will be different depending on the closing date, (2) the notes probably should have the same maturity date despite being issued on different dates, and (3) if the conversion discount or warrant coverage is fixed, investors in a later closing might incur less risk than the earlier investors and perhaps the conversion discount or warrant coverage needs to be adjusted to reflect the difference in risk.
What should the terms of bridge loan warrant coverage be?
1. Type of shares
Typically, the warrant is exercisable for the type of securities issued in the next round of financing. If the company has completed a Series A financing and the bridge loan is a “bridge” to the Series B, then the warrant is exercisable for Series B when the Series B financing is completed. Savvy investors will negotiate a fallback mechanism where the warrant is exercisable for an existing security (such as common or Series A) if the maturity date is reached or if there is a sale of company before the next round of financing.
2. Number of shares/warrant coverage
The number of shares issuable upon exercise of the warrant issued in connection with the convertible note is referred to as “warrant coverage.” Warrant coverage is expressed as a percentage of the principal amount of the note. Calculation of the number of shares based on the warrant coverage percentage typically means:
[number of shares issuable upon exercise of warrant] = [principal amount of loan] * [warrant coverage percentage] / [exercise price per share in the next round of financing]
So 20% warrant coverage on a $500,000 bridge loan assuming that the next round price is $2.00/share would be:
[50,000 shares] = [$500,000] * [0.20] / [$2.00]
The amount of warrant coverage seems to mimic the conversion discount range of 20% to 40%, although higher warrant coverage is not particularly unusual. The amount of warrant coverage is tied to the amount of risk that the investor incurs. Warrant coverage and conversion discounts are mechanisms to compensate the investor for risk.
3. Exercise price
The exercise price of the warrant is typically the price per share in the next round of financing. Sometimes, the exercise price may be fixed at the last round price or some other pre-determined price, especially if the warrant is exercisable for the type of security issued in the previous round or common stock.
4. Term
Most warrants can be exercised for a period of 3 to 7 years from closing of the bridge financing. 5 years is probably common.
5. Termination upon sale of company or IPO
Warrants should expire on a sale of company and probably should expire on an IPO. However, the holder of the warrant will have the ability to exercise the warrant immediately prior to these events. Warrants should expire on a sale of company because acquirors do not want to assume warrants and generally demand that warrants be exercised prior to closing. Although acquirors are willing to assume employee options in a sale of company, holders of warrants typically do not have any relationship with the company after the closing of the sale transaction. Many companies prefer to have warrants expire on an IPO to eliminate the share overhang associated with the warrants.